New Renovation Quote vs. Staying with Your Existing Contractor: When to Switch

You’ve done a renovation with a contractor before. Now you have a new project — do you go back to them or get competing quotes? Both approaches have merit, but the decision framework is straightforward once you know what to look for.

Reasons to Stay with Your Existing Contractor

• Demonstrated quality: They delivered excellent work on the last project. Known quality is worth more than an unknown contractor with a better price.
• They know your home: An existing contractor knows your electrical panel, structural quirks, preferred materials, and communication style. The learning curve savings are real.
• Relationship trust: You’ve navigated a project together and know how they handle issues, changes, and pressure. This has high value.
• Preferred pricing: Repeat clients often receive preferential pricing — contractors value predictable, easy-to-work-with clients.
• No procurement cost: Getting 3 qualified quotes takes 3–6 weeks and significant effort. If the existing contractor is excellent, this cost may not be justified.

Reasons to Get Competing Quotes

• The new project is very different: Your existing contractor excelled at basement suites but this is a laneway home. Different expertise, different risk profile.
• Project is very large: For a $500,000+ renovation, the price difference between contractors can be $50,000–$100,000 — more than worth the quoting effort.
• Previous project had significant issues: Schedule overruns, cost surprises, communication failures, or quality defects are signals to test alternatives.
• You want a design-build approach: Some contractors offer integrated design services; others are construction-only. A different project type may require a different contractor type.

Getting Competing Quotes Without Burning the Relationship

It’s legitimate to say: “I value our working relationship and would like to work with you again. I’m also getting two other quotes as due diligence — I hope you understand.” A confident, legitimate contractor won’t be offended. Only a contractor who knows their price is uncompetitive will object to competitive quoting.

How to get multiple quotes efficiently → | Request a VGC quote →

→ See also: Vancouver Renovation Planning Guide

More Planning & Financing Guides

Smart Lighting Installation During Home Renovation in Vancouver: Options and What It's Worth

Heat Pump Installation in Vancouver: Air-Source vs Ground-Source and CleanBC Rebates

Home Automation on a Renovation Budget: What's Worth It in a Vancouver Home

Structured Wiring During Home Renovation in Vancouver: Future-Proofing Your Home Network

Home Security System Installation During Renovation in Vancouver: Cameras, Sensors, and Smart Locks

VGC Editorial Team

✓ Licensed Contractor500+ Projects15 Years Experience

Vancouver General Contractors has completed 500+ home renovations across Metro Vancouver since 2010. Our articles are written and reviewed by licensed contractors, project managers, and renovation specialists with hands-on field experience.

1044 renovation guides published on this site.

About VGC →