Vancouver custom home renovation with modern pool design
Planning & Financing2 min readMar 20, 2026

General Contractor vs. Hiring Sub-Trades Directly in Vancouver: True Cost Comparison

Conventional wisdom says hiring sub-trades directly saves the 15–25% general contractor markup. But the calculation is far more complex than that. Here’s an honest analysis.

The Math: Where the GC Markup Goes

A general contractor charges 15–25% over trade costs. This markup covers:

  • Project management (schedule coordination, daily supervision, subcontrade management): 5–8%
  • Insurance premium (contractor’s CGL policy covering your project): 1–2%
  • Permit acquisition and compliance: 1–2%
  • Site overhead (tools, consumables, cleanup, waste disposal): 2–3%
  • Warranty and deficiency management: 2–3%
  • Profit margin: 3–8%

If you hire sub-trades directly, you are taking on all of the first four categories yourself.

What Self-Managing a Renovation Actually Costs You

Your Time (The Hidden Cost)

Managing a $150,000 renovation requires approximately 200–300 hours of owner time: sourcing and quoting trades, coordinating schedules, ordering materials, managing deliveries, handling inspections, resolving disputes, and making daily decisions. At a conservative $100/hr opportunity cost, that’s $20,000–$30,000 in time — more than the GC markup you saved.

Trade Sequencing Mistakes

Trades must be sequenced precisely: demo → rough plumbing → rough electrical → framing inspections → insulation → drywall → cabinet rough-in → tile → cabinets → plumbing trim → electrical trim → appliances → punch list. An experienced GC knows these sequences and has relationships with inspectors. A first-time project manager will almost certainly need at least one re-sequence, adding cost and time.

Trade Access: Direct Hiring is Harder Than It Sounds

Vancouver’s good tradespeople are booked 3–6 months out and prefer to work through trusted GCs. Direct-hiring homeowners are last priority. You will either wait longer or accept less experienced tradespeople.

When Direct Hiring Actually Makes Sense

Direct hiring can work when: you are a construction professional yourself; the project is a single trade (only plumbing, only electrical — not a full renovation); or you are doing a DIY project with one or two licensed inspections. For multi-trade renovations, the GC markup typically delivers more value than it costs.

How to evaluate a GC → | Get a VGC quote →

→ See also: Vancouver Renovation Planning Guide

Ready to start your renovation?

Bryan Baeumler with the Vancouver General Contractors team
Baeumler Approved
Baeumler Approved

Trusted by Canada’s
Top Building Experts

“I only put my name on companies I’d hire myself.”

— Bryan Baeumler, HGTV
15+Years in
Business
✓Fixed Price
Guarantee
Baeumler
Approved
VGC
VGC Editorial Team
✓ Licensed Contractor500+ Projects15 Years Experience

Vancouver General Contractors has completed 500+ home renovations across Metro Vancouver since 2010. Our articles are written and reviewed by licensed contractors, project managers, and renovation specialists with hands-on field experience.

1239 renovation guides published on this site.

About VGC →