Vancouver custom home renovation with modern pool design
Planning & Financing2 min readMar 20, 2026

Houzz vs. HomeStars vs. Google vs. Referrals: How Vancouver Homeowners Find Contractors

Where you find your contractor matters — different platforms attract different types of contractors and have different quality signals. Here’s an honest look at each.

Google Search and Google Reviews

Best for: Initial research, reputation validation, reading unfiltered reviews.

Google reviews are the most trusted review source because they cannot be removed by the contractor and the platform does minimal editorial filtering. A contractor with 80+ Google reviews at 4.4+ stars is genuinely good — that score requires consistent positive client experiences over years. Red flags: very few reviews, a cluster of reviews all posted on the same day (often a campaign), or no response to negative reviews.

HomeStars

Best for: Comparing contractors with verified project reviews in a specific service category.

HomeStars verifies that reviewers have actually hired the contractor and validates business licences. The “Best of HomeStars” award is a genuine quality signal — it requires consistent review scores over multiple years. Limitation: contractors pay to be featured, so ordering reflects promotion budget, not quality.

Houzz

Best for: Portfolio evaluation, design-style matching, photo research.

Houzz is strongest as a portfolio platform — seeing before/after photos of actual projects gives you a much stronger quality signal than any review. A contractor with 20+ project photos showing consistent craftsmanship quality across multiple project types is a stronger indicator than reviews alone. Limitation: not all contractors have active Houzz profiles.

Personal Referrals

Best for: High trust, known-quantity contractors.

A referral from a friend or neighbour who had a similar project done well is the highest-trust starting point. The limitation is sample size — your friend’s excellent experience doesn’t guarantee yours, especially if project type or scale differs significantly. Use referrals as a starting point, not a substitute for due diligence.

Bark.com, Trusted Pros, HomeAdvisor

Best for: Quick quotes on smaller projects.

These platforms match homeowners with contractors quickly. Quality is more variable — contractors on these platforms pay per-lead fees, which can attract less established contractors. Best used for smaller, well-defined projects ($5,000–$30,000) where the quote process is straightforward.

The Recommended Approach for a Major Renovation

1. Ask 2–3 people in your network with similar homes/renovations for referrals. 2. Verify each referral’s Google reviews and HomeStars profile. 3. Search Google for the top-rated contractors in your specific service category. 4. Get 3 quotes. 5. Verify WCB, insurance, and licence for your top 2. 6. Check their Houzz portfolio if available.

How to verify contractor credentials → | Get a VGC quote →

→ See also: Vancouver Renovation Planning Guide

Ready to start your renovation?

Bryan Baeumler with the Vancouver General Contractors team
Baeumler Approved
Baeumler Approved

Trusted by Canada’s
Top Building Experts

“I only put my name on companies I’d hire myself.”

— Bryan Baeumler, HGTV
15+Years in
Business
✓Fixed Price
Guarantee
Baeumler
Approved
VGC
VGC Editorial Team
✓ Licensed Contractor500+ Projects15 Years Experience

Vancouver General Contractors has completed 500+ home renovations across Metro Vancouver since 2010. Our articles are written and reviewed by licensed contractors, project managers, and renovation specialists with hands-on field experience.

1239 renovation guides published on this site.

About VGC →