Should You Renovate or Buy a New Home in Metro Vancouver?
With average Vancouver detached home prices above $2M, the decision to renovate vs buy new is one of the most significant financial decisions a homeowner can make. Understanding the trade-offs is critical.
Cost Comparison: Renovate vs Buy
Scenario
Approximate Cost
Full renovation (current home)
$200,000–$600,000
Buy comparable newer home
$2,000,000–$3,500,000 (detached)
PTT on new purchase ($2.5M)
~$57,500
Realtor commissions (3.5%)
~$87,500
Moving costs + setup
$10,000–$30,000
When to Renovate
Love your neighbourhood and neighbours
Kids in school with strong connections to community
Current mortgage rate is excellent (below today’s market)
Current home has strong bones (good structure, good location)
Renovation will deliver the exact functionality you need
When to Buy New
Current home has fundamental flaws (layout, lot size, location)
Renovation would cost 70%+ of equivalent move-up purchase
Family needs are significantly different from current home’s capacity
Rental income opportunity at destination exceeds renovation ROI
“I only put my name on companies I’d hire myself.”
— Bryan Baeumler, HGTV
15+Years in Business
✓Fixed Price Guarantee
Baeumler Approved
VGC Editorial Team
✓ Licensed Contractor500+ Projects15 Years Experience
Vancouver General Contractors has completed 500+ home renovations across Metro Vancouver since 2010. Our articles are written and reviewed by licensed contractors, project managers, and renovation specialists with hands-on field experience.